Citizen Soldiers by: Stephen E. Ambrose - Alberto R

    Stephen E. Ambrose's book "Citizen Soldiers" and John Eisenhower's writings offer profound insight into the experiences of ordinary soldiers during World War II, highlighting their resilience, resourcefulness, and unwavering commitment in the line of fire. Ambrose focused on the contributions of citizen soldiers, rather than just the actions of generals. This book provides a more nuanced perspective on the war. Through vivid accounts of bravery and courage, Ambrose illuminates the untold stories of those who fought not for glory, but out of a sense of duty and a desire to uphold what is right. As Ambrose guides readers through pivotal moments like the Battle of the Bulge, connections to broader historical narratives become apparent, underscoring the sacrifices made by millions of soldiers, often overlooked in popular retellings of the war.


    One particular story from Ambrose's book really tells and shows the experiences of ordinary soldiers: that of Lieutenant General Brian Horrocks, commander of the British XXX Corps, in November 1944. Horrocks found himself commanding the inexperienced U.S. 84th Infantry Division, tasked with leading the attack on Geilenkirchen, situated north of Aachen on the Dutch-German border. Upon arriving at the division's location, his encounter with an American sentry highlights the disconnect between commanders and frontline troops, a theme emphasized in Ambrose's analysis of the U.S. Army's European Theater of Operations.


    Horrocks' response to the situation reflects the adaptability of citizen soldiers. Recognizing the urgency imposed by harsh winter conditions and the inexperience of the 84th Division, he promptly dispatched support from the 43rd Wessex Division, the Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry, as well as artillery and specialized tank units, to aid the Americans. He also ensures the provision of hot meals and dry socks to boost morale among the troops.


    The Battle of Geilenkirchen, described by Horrocks as one of the hardest fought actions in the European theater, sees the 84th Division securing its objectives through intense combat at the battalion, company, and platoon levels. Horrocks' admiration for the courage and bravery displayed by the soldiers reflects Ambrose's portrayal of the resilience and adaptability of ordinary soldiers.


    Through personal accounts and detailed historical analysis, Ambrose captures the essence of the American soldier's experience in World War II, honoring their sacrifices and unwavering determination. 

    Overall I really liked this book and I would really recommend it to everyone as said before provides a perspective of the war through the eyes of ordinary soldiers. 9/10

Comments

  1. KrishApril 15, 2024 at 6:44 AM

    Hi Alberto, I think this is a good book and this has a lot of millitary information. Nice Job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Daniel LeeApril 15, 2024 at 7:07 AM

    Hi Alberto. This is a great blog. You really frame this book as a book that provides insight into stories that would commonly be disregarded. Why did you choose to give this book a 9/10 though? what prevented it from becoming a 10/10? Anyways, great blog.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yuto InoueApril 15, 2024 at 11:32 AM

    Hello Alberto. I agree with Daniel about why you gave it a 9/10 instead of 10/10 as you don't give many negative aspects of the book. Was it just because 10/10 would be a perfect score? I think I would enjoy reading this book, as it seems to have a lot of information and create intense combat scenes. Nice post.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ElliotthegreatApril 30, 2024 at 6:52 PM

    Hi Alberto, as a person who really has an interest in military I like how you gave so more information on the tragic realities of war. Good Job!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Star Wars vs Harry Potter by Henry G

 Star Wars and Harry Potter are two of the most iconic fantasy novel and movie series. While these two series may seem quite different at first, with one using wands, and the other using lightsabers, the main character in both series actually have quite a lot in common. First off, both Harry and Luke did not grow up with their parents because they were dead (or believed to be). Instead, they were raised by their aunts and uncles and later taken away by an old man from a secret organization related to their parents. At the end, both characters eventually defeat the villain who is somehow related to their family. Harry's parents, who were wizards, were killed and Harry was raised by his aunt and uncle. Then, Hagrid takes him and introduces him to the wizarding world, where he would follow the footsteps of his parents and eventually defeat Voldemort, who killed his parents. Luke's parents were also dead or believed to be dead and Luke grew up with his aunt and uncle in a fairly no...
Read more

Hatchet: A Disappointing Novel (With Spoilers) - Abdurrahman

Image
  As a new member of this blog group, I wanted to skim the blogs my new blogmates posted and read a few. While doing so, one blog caught my eye: a book review of Hatchet by my fellow blogmate, Alberto. As I read his exhilarating review of the book, I immediately added this book to my to-be-read list, and here I am with a review of Hatchet . Today, for the first time ever, I am sad to proclaim that my review is mostly a dissatisfied one of Hatchet . Hatchet , by Gary Paulsen, was published in 1986. It begins with thirteen-year-old Brian Robeson riding a tiny plane above the Canadian forests, on a trip from New York to visit his father in northern Canada. Suddenly, the pilot he’s sitting next to suffers a fatal heart attack and, soaring above the wilderness at 70,000 feet, he’s alone in a dreadful situation. After the miraculous survival of the crash, which sends the plane deep in a lake, Brian must learn the way of the caveman. With only a hatchet from his mother and the resour...
Read more

A review of Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card - Henry

Image
 Ender's game is a sci-fi novel by Orson Scott Card published in 1985. While it seems quite old for a sci-fi novel, it's a true classic and one of my favorite sci-fi novels. In this blog, I will talk about why I like this book so much and what made me want to constantly revisit this book. In Ender’s Game (1985), a little boy named Andrew ‘Ender’ Wiggin is recruited by the International Fleet for its Battle School, a training school for the best children in the world so that they can meet an alien invasion that’s just around the corner. Ender is short but tactically brilliant and a great leader, and he quickly learns how to take orders. He also learns how to obey his masters, who lie manipulatively to him at every turn. His brilliance and gifts tend to come with loneliness and isolation, as he begins to “win” battles and get promoted in his training. The alien threat becomes his playground. Of course it wouldn’t be a military sci-fi novel if young genius Ender didn’t wreak total...
Read more